Gaming and TV fans are going wild after The Walking Dead legend Jeffrey Dean Morgan declared his dream role: playing Arthur Morgan in a potential live-action Red Dead Redemption series or movie. The Negan actor didn’t hold back during a recent fan convention Q&A, saying he’d jump at the chance “in a heartbeat” – and even joked he’d do it “for free”!
When a fan asked if he’d be interested in starring as the iconic outlaw from Red Dead Redemption 2 amid the boom in video game adaptations (like The Last of Us and Fallout), Morgan lit up: “That’s the one that I want to do! It’s not even a question. My favorite genre is westerns – there’s not even a close second. My son plays that game and it’s freaking awesome. In a heartbeat, I would do it for free.”
(He quickly added with a laugh: don’t actually take the “free” part seriously!)
Morgan’s passion makes total sense. He’s built a career on tough, charismatic anti-heroes – from Negan in The Walking Dead to John Winchester in Supernatural. His gruff voice, intense presence, and ability to blend menace with charm scream Western outlaw.
Why Fans Are Divided on This Casting
The internet exploded with reactions. Many love the idea:
- Morgan’s rugged look and emotional depth could nail Arthur’s tragic redemption arc.
- His love for Westerns and personal connection (his son plays RDR2) feels genuine.
But others point out a big issue: age. Arthur Morgan is canonically 36 in Red Dead Redemption 2, while Jeffrey Dean Morgan is 59. Fans on Reddit and X argue he’d be a better fit for Dutch van der Linde – the charismatic, manipulative gang leader with that perfect villainous vibe Morgan mastered as Negan.
Common fan comments:
- “He’d be an incredible Dutch – that voice and swagger!”
- “Too old for Arthur, but sign him up for the gang anyway.”
- Some insist no one can replace Roger Clark’s voice/motion capture performance.
Is a Red Dead Redemption Live-Action Adaptation Happening?
Sadly, no official plans from Rockstar Games yet. Despite massive demand and successful game-to-screen hits, Rockstar remains super selective about adaptations – prioritizing creative control. No announcements for a Red Dead Redemption series or movie in 2025 or beyond.
That hasn’t stopped dream casting though! Henry Cavill, Jack Black, and even original voice actor Roger Clark have expressed interest in RDR projects over the years.
Morgan’s viral comments have reignited the hype. With video game adaptations dominating (Arcane Season 2 crushing records, Fallout renewed), a cinematic Western epic like RDR2’s story – full of betrayal, honor, and stunning landscapes – feels inevitable.
Would you watch Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Arthur (or Dutch)? Who’s your dream casting for a live-action Red Dead Redemption? Drop your thoughts in the comments – let’s debate!
Stay tuned for more news.