After years of fan hopes, rumors, and trending hashtags like #MakeTASM3, actor Andrew Garfield has finally addressed one of the biggest questions in superhero fandom: will The Amazing Spider-Man 3 ever happen? Unfortunately, Garfield doesn’t sound optimistic. In a recent interview, he admitted that he doesn’t think the long-awaited sequel will ever see the light of day — dashing hopes for another swing through the Sony Spider-Man universe.

But what does this mean for his version of Peter Parker? And why has Garfield’s Spider-Man become even more beloved years after his original films ended? Let’s break down everything we know.

The Rise and Fall of The Amazing Spider-Man Franchise

Back in 2012, The Amazing Spider-Man rebooted the franchise just five years after Sam Raimi’s trilogy ended. Directed by Marc Webb and starring Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone, the film took a darker, more emotional tone — reimagining Peter Parker’s origin story for a new generation.

The first film performed solidly, grossing $758 million worldwide, and was praised for its grounded storytelling and the chemistry between Garfield and Stone. Sony quickly greenlit a sequel, envisioning The Amazing Spider-Man 2 as the launching pad for a sprawling cinematic universe featuring Sinister Six, Venom, and even Black Cat spin-offs.

However, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014) underperformed critically, with many fans criticizing its crowded plot and setup-heavy narrative. Despite its strong box office numbers ($708 million globally), it fell short of expectations. Soon after, Sony’s hack in 2014 revealed behind-the-scenes chaos, leading to a historic deal with Marvel Studios to integrate Spider-Man into the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU).

And just like that, The Amazing Spider-Man 3 was shelved indefinitely.

Andrew Garfield Finally Breaks His Silence

In a recent sit-down interview, Garfield addressed the long-debated sequel with honesty and finality:

“I don’t think The Amazing Spider-Man 3 will ever happen.”

For many fans, this felt like closure — but also heartbreak. Garfield’s portrayal of Spider-Man has aged like fine wine. While initially divisive, his emotional depth and vulnerable approach to the character gained renewed appreciation after his return in Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021). His redemption arc in that film, saving MJ after failing to save Gwen Stacy, was one of the most emotional moments in the MCU’s history.

Garfield added in past interviews that while he’s deeply grateful for his time as Spider-Man, he believes that story “found its natural ending.” Still, his openness to reprising the role in the right context — like a multiverse project — leaves the door slightly ajar.

Fan Campaigns: The Power of #MakeTASM3

After Garfield’s return in No Way Home, fans reignited their campaign for #MakeTASM3 across social media platforms. Memes, concept posters, and petitions flooded X (Twitter), Reddit, and Instagram, urging Sony to give Garfield his long-overdue trilogy finale.

The campaign grew so loud that even Sony Pictures executives reportedly noticed the trend. Rumors circulated that Sony was considering using Garfield’s Spider-Man in its Venom and Morbius universe, especially after the multiverse cracks opened in No Way Home.

But despite the fan enthusiasm, no official development was ever announced. Sony’s focus shifted toward Tom Holland’s Spider-Man 4, Venom 3, and the upcoming Spider-Man Noir series for Prime Video.

Comparing the Three Spider-Men

Each live-action Spider-Man actor brought something unique to the role.

• Tobey Maguire embodied the nostalgic, everyday hero with a classic tone.
• Tom Holland represents the MCU’s youthful, tech-savvy version.
• Andrew Garfield, however, stands out for his emotional realism — a Spider-Man defined by guilt, love, and loss.

Garfield’s Peter Parker was more raw and human. His chemistry with Emma Stone’s Gwen Stacy remains unmatched, often cited as one of the most authentic romances in superhero films. Many fans argue that his Spider-Man had the most unfinished arc — which is why calls for The Amazing Spider-Man 3 never faded.

Why The Amazing Spider-Man 3 Never Happened

Sony’s cancellation of The Amazing Spider-Man 3 boiled down to a mix of timing, corporate politics, and creative fatigue. The leaked Sony emails from 2014 showed an internal struggle over the franchise’s direction. Meanwhile, Marvel Studios offered a tempting solution: bring Spider-Man into the MCU, rebooted with Tom Holland.

The deal meant Garfield’s version was left behind — not because of his performance, but because of a larger business strategy. By aligning Spider-Man with the Avengers, Sony ensured box office success and creative stability, something the standalone Amazing Spider-Man films lacked.

Sony’s Spider-Verse: Is There Still Hope?

While The Amazing Spider-Man 3 might never happen, Garfield’s Spider-Man still fits perfectly into the evolving Sony Spider-Verse.

Projects like Venom, Madame Web, and Kraven the Hunter have established a darker, edgier tone that could easily suit Garfield’s Peter Parker. Many fans believe his version could exist in the same continuity as Tom Hardy’s Venom — something teased in No Way Home’s post-credits scene.

Moreover, the upcoming Avengers: Secret Wars (2027) promises major multiverse crossovers. Marvel could easily bring back Garfield for a cameo, if not a full story arc, uniting him with both Holland and Maguire once more.

Andrew Garfield’s Relationship with the Role

Despite the bittersweet end of his Spider-Man chapter, Garfield’s love for the role remains clear. In multiple interviews, he’s expressed deep gratitude to the fans who have embraced his version years after the films released.

He also revealed that the experience taught him resilience:

“I got to play a character who taught me how to get back up after falling.”

Since then, Garfield has earned critical acclaim for films like Tick, Tick… Boom! and The Eyes of Tammy Faye, proving his versatility beyond the superhero genre. Still, Spider-Man remains a defining part of his legacy — a role he calls “a sacred experience.”

The Legacy of The Amazing Spider-Man

Even if The Amazing Spider-Man 3 never swings into existence, its impact on pop culture endures. Garfield’s emotional and nuanced portrayal reshaped how audiences perceive superhero storytelling — not just as action-packed blockbusters, but as deeply human tales of love, loss, and redemption.

In the grand tapestry of Spider-Man history, Garfield’s iteration stands as a bridge between eras — from Raimi’s classic storytelling to Marvel’s modern spectacle. While we may never see his Peter Parker headline another solo film, his return in No Way Home proved one thing: heroes never truly fade, especially when fans keep their faith alive.